Shedeur Sanders has spent most of the 2026 NFL season watching from the sideline. On Sunday, he may finally have the opportunity to show Cleveland if he can lead an NFL franchise.
The timing couldn’t be more interesting, considering the NFL trade deadline is just days away.
Browns starting quarterback Deshaun Watson entered concussion protocol this week following Cleveland’s 27-6 loss to Pittsburgh, opening the door for Sanders to make his first start of the season against New Orleans.
Watson hasn’t officially been ruled out, but Sanders has been taking first-team practice reps while Cleveland prepares for the possibility of a quarterback change.
Head coach Todd Monken didn’t hide his enthusiasm when discussing the opportunity Wednesday.
“I can’t wait to see him let it rip today and see where we’re at,” Monken said.
It’s an encouraging statement from a coach who watched Sanders compete for the starting job throughout training camp. But there’s a difference between being excited to see what a young quarterback can do and being convinced he’s ready to lead an NFL offense.
That’s distinction is worth examining as Sunday approaches.
Sanders started seven games during his rookie season, throwing for 1,400 yards, seven touchdowns and 10 interceptions while leading Cleveland to a 3-4 record in those appearances.
There were encouraging moments, particularly when he extended plays and attacked defenses downfield. But the inconsistency was difficult to ignore. Sanders occasionally held the ball too long seemingly struggling to recognize pressure and made decisions that turned manageable situations into long yardage downs.
If Sanders gets the start Sunday, those are the areas where I’ll be looking for improvement.
At Colorado, Sanders developed a reputation for keeping plays alive long enough to find receivers downfield. His confidence in his arm and ability to create outside the pocket were significant parts of his success in Boulder.
But defensive windows close faster in the NFL and pass rushers rarely give quarterbacks the luxury of waiting for something to develop.
I think it is important that Sanders doesn’t abandon the instincts that made him successful. He needs to become more selective about when to trust them.
That means recognizing when a play has run its course and getting the football out on time.
It’s an adjustment that separates quarterbacks who occasionally produce impressive highlights from those capable of consistently operating an NFL offense.
Cleveland has already demonstrated that it can win football games without asking its quarterback to carry the entire team.
Watson has helped guide the Browns to a 5-3 record. His resurgence has given Cleveland stability at a position that entered the season surrounded by uncertainty.
Sanders would be stepping into a team with legitimate postseason aspirations, which changes the expectations from his rookie season.
He isn’t being asked to audition during a meaningless stretch of games. Cleveland needs to win, and Sanders’ responsibility would be to give the Browns their best opportunity to do exactly that.
Against New Orleans, I’ll be watching how he handles early downs, particularly whether he can keep the offense ahead of the chains instead of repeatedly facing obvious passing situations.
His performance on third down will also be revealing. Can he identify favorable matchups before the snap? Will he recognize pressure quickly enough to make the correct adjustment?
There is also the question of how Sanders responds when things inevitably go wrong. What matters is whether he can avoid allowing one mistake to become several.
That composure will be especially important against a New Orleans defense that has struggled this season. The Saints enter Sunday’s matchup ranked near the bottom of the league in several major defensive categories, presenting Sanders with an opportunity to establish a rhythm.
A favorable matchup doesn’t guarantee a favorable performance, however.
And even if Sanders plays well, one game shouldn’t suddenly erase the concerns surrounding his development.
But it could change the conversation about his future.
The NFL trade deadline arrives Tuesday, November 10, and Sanders’ name has already surfaced in speculation about potential quarterback movement.
A strong showing against New Orleans could make him more appealing to teams looking for a young quarterback with starting potential.
But that possibility deserves some perspective.
Quarterback-needy franchises aren’t likely to make a significant investment based solely on one encouraging performance. Teams have an entire rookie season of Sanders’ film to evaluate, along with his preseason work and the circumstances surrounding his current position on Cleveland’s depth chart.
A productive Sunday might strengthen his value, but it wouldn’t suddenly make him a proven starter.
There’s also no indication that Cleveland is obligated to move him. With Watson’s health uncertain and the Browns competing for a playoff position, keeping a capable backup could be more valuable than receiving a modest draft pick.
The more realistic opportunity for Sanders may be to demonstrate that he deserves serious consideration for a starting role, whether that eventually comes in Cleveland or somewhere else.
And that begins with showing improvement in the areas that previously limited him.
What would impress me Sunday isn’t necessarily a 300-yard passing performance or a collection of long down-field throws. I’d rather see Sanders operate efficiently, protect the football and make the decisions necessary to keep Cleveland competitive.
We already know he has the arm talent to produce big plays, what we still need to see is whether he can consistently handle the responsibilities that come between those moments.
Monken wants to see Sanders let it rip, and the NFL would love to see a ratings explosion in Cleveland considering Shedeur draws eyeballs.
But for Sanders, the most valuable performance might be one that demonstrates a little more restraint than we’ve seen in the past.
Sunday could give Sanders another chance to showcase his talent. What will determine his NFL future is whether he can prove he’s learned how to win with it.
Players Mentioned
